Martha Marcy May Marlene (2011)
November 25th, 2011Martha Marcy May Marlene (USA) Directed by Sean Durkin Written by Sean Durkin Starring Elizabeth Olsen; Sarah Paulson; John Hawkes; Hugh Dancy; Brady Corbet; Louisa Krause; Julie Garner; Adma David Thompson; Maria Dizzle (Katie); Christopher Abbott (Max)
Twenty nine year old Sean Durkin writes and directs his first feature - a story about Martha (Elizabeth Olsen), a young woman who manages to escape an isolated cult farm in upstate New York, and is then haunted by her experiences as she attempts to re-adjust to everyday life.
The film caused a splash at Sundance, with awards going to the director and his twenty two year old lead, plaudits that prove to be deserving. Despite its low budget origins and limited locations, Durkin demonstrates a steady hand, and a cast containing the likes of John Hawkes (as cult leader Patrick); Hugh Dancy (as brother in law Ted); and Sarah Paulson (as older sister Lucy) are uniformly strong.
Younger sister of the famous twins, Mary-Kate and Ashley, Elizabeth Olsen gives the kind of breakout turn that comes along about once every year or two when an actor emerges from virtual obscurity to give a performance with the kind of breadth worthy of a quality veteran. It’s the kind of thoughtful, low key job marking the best work there is - behavior with invisible seams, on camera thought that never feels forced or contrived, emotion deriving from a true place as opposed to seeming divorced from on screen events.
Part of a producing team/company who made the indie Afterschool (2008), Durkin is also clearly a director on the rise. Broken into two sections - Martha’s experience at the cult told mostly in a series of flashbacks; and the initial days when she returns to real life, moving in with her sister and new husband into their expensive Connecticut vacation rental by the lake. Durkin manages to merge these two time frames - Martha in the present, beset with waking and sleeping dreams of the near past that intrude on her attempts at adjustment. Though this is a psychological drama, Durkin refuses the conventions of genre, and instead underplays the events, recognizing the emotion underneath the surface, but never punctuating Martha’s inner demons, or the domestic turmoil at play.
Paulson and Hawkes, two excellent actors who were both part of the cast of the late, great HBO series Deadwood, do their usual strong work. Though it’s difficult not to draw comparisons to famous real life types like Charles Manson, David Koresh, and Jim Jones, Hawkes seems to avoid the trap of impression, underplaying the role by straying from his soft spoken countenance only in several key moments, the power of his portrayal arising out of the very banal, methodical nature of his control. In a similar way, Paulson’s Lucy is a woman holding on to tremendous repressed guilt over not caring for her sister when their mother died, and the perfect life she and her seemingly not so kind new husband have precariously embarked upon becomes threatened by Martha’s strange, disruptive presence.
The inner workings of the cult feel nicely researched, with Patrick preying on the subjugated young women and exhorting militaristic like control over the men. These sections could have easily become didactic with a less skilled storyteller attempting to inform the audience all he/she knows about cults, but instead the scenes feel organic and grounded, and bits and pieces of life on the farm are delivered in a series of non-linear memories that never feel disjointed, confusing, or manipulative.
The camera loves the doe-eyed Olsen, and she rewards our interest by never forcing or pushing, but rather relaxes into her role, making even scenes with her sitting, or staring, or speaking one or two lines mean something. Yes, she is emotionally dulled, and in various stages of brainwashing throughout, but she remains compelling primarily because she is never “playing” at these various states. This ease also allows her personality to poke through in small ways, giving hints at what she may have been like previously.
In fact, all of Durkin’s characters are given the breadth to be actual human beings, and are not just one thing - particularly in the case of Lucy, who exhibits generosity toward, and concern for, her sister, but also demonstrates streaks of self-absorption and pettiness. One is left with the distinct impression of a woman with a less than intact interior life trying to piece it together. Martha’s presence seems to shine a flashlight on the tentative construct of who she has become, and several comments made by Martha wind up cutting to the heart of Lucy and Ted’s insecurities.
Durkin shows the same deftness with the dance that takes place between Martha’s dream and waking states, which are melded with her present and past life. Though there are obvious questions about Martha’s emotional fitness, the director doesn’t rely on showy camera tricks or visual effects to illustrate this concept - Images, Sisters, Three Women, or Repulsion this is not. Present, past, and dreams are played straight, and while Durkin often employs cuts that have us unsure of where we are as move to the other world, the transitions are handled smoothly and modestly, and have the effect of placing us alongside Martha as she bounces back and forth inside her head.
The title comes from Martha’s name (Martha); the name given to her by Patrick (Marcy May); and an alias used by the cult’s female residents when people from the outside call the farmhouse (Marlene), though metaphorically it could stand for the many facets of any human being/the multiple parts of self - what we tell ourselves; what we show the world; and how the world perceives us.
























